1.“World history is the history of large cultures.”Oswald Spengler,Decline of the West(New York:A.A.Knopf,1926-1928),II,170.The major works by these scholars analyzing the nature and dynamics of civilizations include:Max Weber,The Sociology of Religion (Boston:Beacon Press,trans.Ephraim Fischoff,1968);Emile Durkheim and Marcel Mauss,“Note on the Notion of Civilization,”Social Research,38(1971),808-813;Oswald Spengler,Decline of the West;Pitirim Sorokin,Social and Cultural Dynamics (New York:American Book Co.,4 vols.,1937-1985);Arnold Toynbee,A Study of History (London:Oxford University Press,12 vols.,1934-1961 );Alfred Weber,Kulturgeschichte als Kultursoziologie(Leiden:A.W.Sijthoff’s Uitgerversmaatschappij N.V.,1935);A.L.Kroeber,Configurations of Culture Growth (Berkeley:University of California Press,1944),and Style and Civilizations (Westport,CT:Greenwood Press,1973);Philip Bagby,Culture and History:Prolegomena to the Comparative Study of Civilizations (London:Longmans,Green,1958); Carroll Quigley,The Evolution of Civilizations:An Introduction to Historical Analysis (New York:Macmillan,1961 );Rushton Coulborn,The Origin of Civilized Societies(Princeton:Princeton University Press,1959);S.N.Eisenstadt,“Cultural Traditions and Political Dynamics:The Origins and Modes of Ideological Politics,”British Journal of Sociology,32 (June 1981),155-181;Fernand Braudel,History of Civilizations(New York:Allen Lane—Penguin Press,1994) and On History (Chicage:University of Chicago Press,1980);William H.McNeill,The Rise of the West :A History of the Human Community (Chicago:University of Chicago Press,1963);Adda B.Bozeman, “Civilizations Under Stress,”Virginia Quarterly Review,51 (Winter 1975 ),1-18, Strategic Intelligence and Statecraft( Washington:Brassey’s (US),1992 ),and Politics and Culture in International History:From the Ancient Near East to the Opening of the Modern Age ( New Brunswick,NJ :Transaction Publishers,1994);Christopher Dawson, Dynamics of World History (LaSalle,IL:Sherwood Sugden Co.,1978),and The Movement of World Revolution (New York:Sheed and Ward,1959);Immanuel Wallerstein,Geopolitics and Geoculture:Essays on the Changing World-system (Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1992);Felipe Fernandez-Armesto,Millennium:A History of the Last Thousand Years (New York:Scribners,1995).To these works could be added the last,tragically marked work of Louis Hartz,A Synthesis of World History (Zurich:Humanity Press,1983),which“with remarkable prescience,”as Samuel Beer commented,“foresees a division of mankind very much like the present pattern of the post-Cold War world”into five great“culture areas”:Christian,Muslim,Hindu, Confucian,and African.Memorial Minute,Louis Hartz,Harvard university Gazette, 89 (May 27,1994).An indispensable summary overview and introduction to the analysis of civilizations is Matthew Melko,The Nature of Civilizations (Boston:Porter Sargent,1969).I am also indebted for useful suggestions to the critical paper on my Foreign Affairs article by Hayward W.Alker,Jr.,“If Not Huntington’s.Civilizations,.Then Whose?”(unpublished paper,Massachusetts Insitute of Technology,25 March 1994). ↩
2.Braudel,On History,pp.177-181,212-214,and History of Civilizations,pp.4-5;Gerrit W.Gong,The Standard of“Civilization”in International Society (Oxford;Clarendon Press,1984),81ff.,97-100;Wallerstein,Geopolitics and Geoculture,pp.160ff.and 215ff.;Arnold J.Toynbee,Study of History,X,274-275,and Civilization on Trial (New York:Oxford University Press,1948),p.24. ↩
3.Braudel,On History,p.205.For an extended review of definitions of culture and civilization,especially the German distinction,see A.L.Kroeber and Clyde Kluckhohn,Culture:A Critical Review of Concepts and Definitions (Cambridge:Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology,Harvard Vniversity,Vol.Ⅺ Ⅶ,No.1,1952),passim but esp.pp.15-29. ↩
4.Bozeman,“Civilizations Under Stress,”p.1. ↩
5.Durkheim and Mauss,“Notion of Civilization,”p.811;Braudel,On History,pp.177,202;Melko,Nature of Civilizations,p.8;Wallerstein,Geopolitics and Geoculture,p.215;Dawson,Dynamics of World History,pp.51,402;Spengler,Decline of the West,I,p.31.Interestingly,the International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences (New York:Macmillan and Free Press,ed.David L.Sills,17 vols.,1968) contains no primary article on “civilization”or“civilizations.”The“concept of civilization”(singular) is treated in a subsection of the article called“Urban Revolution,”while civilizations (plural) receive passing mention in an article called“Culture.” ↩
6.Herodotus,The Persian Wars (Harmondsworth,England:Penguin Books,1972),pp.543-544. ↩
7.Edward A.Tiryakian,“Reflections on the Sociology of Civilizations,”Sociological Analysis,35(Summer 1974),125. ↩
8.Toynbee,Study of History,I,455,quoted in Melko,Nature of Civilizations,pp.8-9;and Braudel,On History,p.202. ↩
9.Braudel,History of Civilizations,p.35,and On History,pp.209-210. ↩
10.Bozeman,Strategic Intelligence and Statecraft,p.26. ↩
11.Quigley,Evolution of Civilizations,pp.146ff.;Melko,Nature of Civilizations,pp.101ff.See D.C.Somervell,“Argument”in his abridgment of Arnold J.Toynbee,A Study of History,vols.I-VI (Oxford:Oxford University Press,1946),pp.569ff. ↩
12.Lucian W.Pye,“China:Erratic State,Frustrated Society,”Foreign Affairs,69 (Fall 1990),58. ↩
13.See Quigley,Evolution of Civilizations,chap.3,esp.pp.77,84;Max Weber,“The Social Psychology of the World Religions,”in From Max Weber:Essays in Sociology(London:Routledge,trans.and ed.H.H.Gerth and C.Wright Mills,1991),p.267;Bagby,Culture and History,pp.165-174;Spengler,Decline of the West,Ⅱ, 31ff;Toynbee,Study of History,I ,133;Ⅻ,546-547;Braudel,History of Civilizations,passim;McNeill,The Rise of the West,passim;and Rostovanyi,“Clash of Civilizations,”pp.8-9. ↩
14.Melko,Nature of Civilizations,p.133. ↩
15.Braudel,On History,p.226. ↩
16.For a major 1990s addition to this literature by one who knows both cultures well,see Claudio Veliz,The New World of the Gothic Fox (Berkelely:University of California Prees,1994). ↩
17.See Charles A.and Mary R.Beard,The Rise of American Civilization (New York:Macmillan,2 vols.,1927) and Max Lerner,America as a Civilization (New York:Simon & Schuster,1957).With patriotic boosterism,Lerner argues that“For good or ill,America is what it is-a culture in its own right,with many characteristic lines of power and meaning of its own,ranking with Greece and Rome as one of the great distinctive civilizations of history.” Yet he also admits,“Almost without exception the great theories of history find no room for any concept of America as a civilization in its own right”(pp.58-59). ↩
18.On the role of fragments of European civilization creating nwe societies in North America,Latin America,South Africa,and Australia,see Louis Hartz,The Founding of New Societies:Studies in the History of the United States,Latin America,South Africa, Canada,and Australia (New York:Harcourt,Brace & World,1964). ↩
19.Dawson,Dynamics of World History,p.128.,See also Mary C.Bateson,“Beyond Sovereignty:An Emerging Global Civilization,”in R.B.J.Walker and Saul H.Mendlovitz,eds.,Contending Sovereignties:Redefining Political Community (Boulder:Lynne Rienner,1990),pp.148-149. ↩
20.Toynbee classifies both Therevada and Lamaist Buddhism as fossil civilizations,Study of History,I,35,91-92. ↩
21.See,for example,Bernard Lewis,Islam and the West (New York:Oxford University Press,1993) ;Toynbee,Study of History,chap.Ⅸ,“Contacts between Civilizations in Space ( Encounters between Contemporaries),”Ⅷ,88ff;Benjamin Nelson,“Civilizational Complexes and lntercivilizational Encounters,”Sociological Analysis,34 (Summer 1973),79-105. ↩
22.S.N.Eisenstadt,“Cultural Traditions and Political Dynamics:The Origins and Modes of Ideological Politics,”British Journal of Sociology,32 (June 1981),157,and“The Axial Age:The Emergence of Transcendental Visions and The Rise of Clerics,”Archives Europeennes de Sociologie,22(No.1,1982),298.See also Benjamin I.Schwartz,“The Age of Transcendence in Wisdom,Revolution,and Doubt:Perspectives on the First Millennnium B.C.,”Daedalus,104 (Spring 1975),3.The concept of the Axial Age derives from Karl Jaspers,Vom Ursprung und Ziel der Geschichte (Zurich:Artemisverlag,1949). ↩
23.Toynbee,Civilization on Trial,p.69.Cf.William H.McNeill,The Rise of the West,pp.295-298,who emphasizes the extent to which by the advent of the Christian era,“Organized trade routes,both by land and by sea,…linked the four great cultures of the continent.” ↩
24.Braudel,On History,p.14:“…cultural influence came in small doses,delayed by the length and slowness of the journeys they had to make.If historians are to be believed, the Chinese fashions of the T’ang period(618-907)travelled so slowly that they did not reach the island of Cyprus and the brilliant court of Lusignan until the fifteenth century.From there they spread,at the quicker speed of Mediterranean trade,to France and the eccentric court of Charles Ⅵ,where hennins and shoes with long pointed toes became immensely popular,the heritage of a long vanished world-much as light still reaches us from stars already extinct.” ↩
25.See Toynbee,Study of History,Ⅷ,347-348. ↩
26.McNeill,Rise of the West,p.547. ↩
27.D.K.Fieldhouse,Economics and Empire,1830-1914 (London:Macmillan, 1984),p.3;F.J.C.Hearnshaw,Sea Power and Empire (London:George Harrap and Co,1940),p.179. ↩
28.Geoffrey Parker,The Military Revolution:Military Innovation and the Rise of the West (Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1988),p.4;Michael Howard,“The Military Factor in European Expansion,”in Hedley Bull and Adam Watson,eds.,The Expansion of International Society (Oxford:Clarendon Press,1984).pp.33ff. ↩
29.A.G.Kenwood and A.L.Lougheed,The Growth of the International Economy 1820-1900 (London:Routledge,1992),pp.78-79;Angus Maddison,Dynamic Forces in Capitalist Development (New York:Oxford University Press,1991 ),pp.326-327;Alan S.Blinder,reported in the New York Times,12 March 1995,p.5E.See also Simon Kuznets,“Qtantitalive Aslpects of the Economic Growth of Nations-Ⅹ. Level and Structure of Foreign Trade:Long-term Trends,”Economic Development and Cultural Change,15 (Jan.1967,part Ⅱ),pp.2-10. ↩
30.Charles Tilly,“Reflections on the History of European State-making,”in“Tilly,ed.,The Formation of National States in Western Europe (Princeton:Princeton University Press,1975),p.18. ↩
31.R.R.Palmer,“Frederick the Great,Guibert,Bulow:From Dynastic to National War,”in Peter Paret,ed.,Makers of Modern Strategy from Machiavelli to the Nuclear Age (Princeton:Princeton University Press,1986),p.119. ↩
32.Edward Mortimer,“Christianity and Islam,”International Affairs,67 (Jan.1991),7. ↩
33.Hedley Bull,The Anarchical Society (New York:Columbia University Press,1977),pp.9-13.See also Adam Watson,The Evolution of International Society (London:Routledge,1992),and Barry Buzan,“From International System to International Society:Structural Realism and Regime Theory Meet the English School,”International Organization,47(Summer 1993),327-352,who distinguishes between“civilizational”and“functional”models of international society and concludes that“Civilizational international societies have dominated the historical record”and that there“appear to be no pure cases of functional international societies.”(p.336).
34.Spengler,Decline of the West,I ,93-94. ↩
35.Toynbee,Study of History,I,149ff,154,157ff. ↩
36.Braudel,On History,p.xxxiii. ↩